This week, my heart has been turning over Carroll and Andy Smith's post on nature study and how to live it.
Education, including Nature Study, as Mason told the young lady whom she interviewed to attend her college, is about living. I have thought about it and I have asked myself the question, “Are these (mentioned above) ways of teaching Nature Study more about “doing” Nature Study weekly or are they about “living” Nature Study. We are to develop the habit of living fully and part of that living is relating to nature and knowing the places where we live, not just doing activities, even Mason inspired ones!"Ouch! Even the best of intentions can end up focused on doing rather than being, especially during busy times like this past month!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3655b/3655bffa606a866a0de59315e7164ba87ecc6069" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/67078/67078df8b21f53b60c800a42ea758b45986be237" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a5808/a58086cb519288950d14cdf7b1380dd0838c0dcc" alt=""
For the past few weeks, I've been trying more "sight-seeing" with Pamela. By "sight-seeing", I mean looking around for something outside that is small and within reach and studying it carefully enough to supply a detailed description (pages 45-48). This activity trains observation skills and expressive language and builds vocabulary. Just like picture study, Pamela spent a few minutes observing the attributes of the fungus, knowing a narration will follow.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7f7c3/7f7c3bad7245f9211ec29465375f08c34927921f" alt=""
When she was ready, I asked her to turn around and narrate a description from memory, which I recorded in the video below.I noticed a couple of interesting things.
- She illustrated nominal aphasia quite well: Pamela knows the word branch but what came out of her mouth was bench. Word retrieval glitches are part of her language challenges and thankfully she doesn't feel self-concious about it. We value communication over perfect speech. I understood what she meant and I respect her efforts.
- Her eye movements shift to the right most of the time when she is speaking. She is concentrating so hard on verbalizing what she saw that she can't look at me while figuring out what to say. Lateral eye movements are a sign of answering difficult questions. Just talking requires her to overcome the neurological barriers we feel when asked a challenging question.
- She processed well enough to look up at the tree when I pointed up. RDI gave her another channel of communication and understanding when language fails her. Tapping into nonverbals must be such a relief for her!
- When we had more of a conversation, going back and forth, she attempts to shift attention to me and then quickly looks away as she processes what she is going to say. When she realizes I am going to give her the name of what she described, she is better able to share eye contact because she doesn't have to talk. Once she starts repeating the word fungus, her eye contact becomes uneven again. It reminds me of how far she has come. Ten years ago, listening was just as challenging as talking for her!
A thought struck me that the outdoor life’s bounty provided therapy for her as I alluded to in my ChildLightUSA blogpost called Rethinking the Culture of Therapy. Picking off the fungus worked on her fine motor skills, the domain of occupational therapy. Learning a new word in a contextualized way and expressing what she saw verbally was speech therapy. Touching this squishy gooey stuff—something she could not do fifteen years ago because of her tactile defensiveness—falls under sensory integration therapy. Anyone who has purchased materials for a sensory diet knows how expensive that stuff can be, and the outdoor life offered it for free! Keeping a nature notebook is an artful blend of science, language arts, and art.
If the child is left to himself he will think more and better, if less showily. Let him go and come freely, let him touch real things, and combine his impressions for himself, instead of sitting indoors at a little round table, while a sweet-voiced teacher suggests that he build a stone wall with his wooden blocks, or make a rainbow out of strips of coloured paper, plant straw trees in bead flower-pots. Such teaching fills the mind with artificial associations that must be got rid of before the child can develop independent ideas out of actual experiences.
~ Anne Sullivan, May 8, 1887
3 comments:
Thank you for sharing your insight. I look forward to following future posts and peeping into the past. I am most curious about the schedule Pamela sees. I saw your own colored "plan." Does Pamela refer to that as well, or does she even see a plan?
Calli
Hi, Calli!!!!!
We use our schedule as a guideline, more like a checklist. I print it out in black and white and she highlights things as we finish. Some days we work in no particular order, but others she choses books by chronology, working from B.C. to modern times or the other way around.
Lately things have been so hectic that our days are more hit and miss. Fortunately, RDI has helped her become much more flexible in her thinking.
I wondered where you were!! :) I really enjoyed reading your post and am now going to go back and click on your links!!
Best wishes
Di
Post a Comment